Duchesne man charged with family abuse ‘as bad as it gets’

Posted in Uncategorized on 11/07/2009 by Claudine Dombrowski

Note: Cross posted from [wp angelfury] Battered Mothers Rights – A Human Rights Issue.

Permalink

Duchesne man charged with family abuse ‘as bad as it gets’

By Geoff Liesik

Deseret Newshttp://www.deseretnews.com/article/705342746/Duchesne-man-charged-with-family-abuse-as-bad-as-it-gets.html?pg=2

Published: Friday, Nov. 6, 2009 11:06 p.m. MST

25 comments

FacebookFarkBuzzDiggE-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + -

A Duchesne County man has been arrested in what investigators say is a case of domestic violence that is "as bad as it gets."

The 38-year-old man is accused in court records of beating his wife with everything from a board to his work boots, threatening to kill her if she "didn’t act right" and raping her twice.

He also allegedly stomped repeatedly on his son after the boy ate a piece of cheese without permission.

"It’s been a war zone in their home," said Duchesne County Sheriff’s Sgt. Wade Butterfield, who called the investigation "gut-wrenching."

"I’ve told my kids as they’ve been growing up there’s no such thing as monsters," the sergeant added. "I’ve been lying to them, because there are monsters. This guy is a monster."

The Deseret News is not naming the man in an effort to protect the identities of his alleged victims.

Butterfield said deputies investigating an assault complaint against the man in mid-September were provided with an eight-page narrative by his wife. The document outlined abuse the woman said she and the couple’s five children endured at least weekly over the past 17 years.

Story continues below

"Literally there were too many incidents of domestic violence and child abuse to even separate," the sergeant said. "It was as bad as it gets. We’re just very, very fortunate that somebody didn’t lose their life."

During an interview in October, the woman told authorities she "lived a life of complete servitude" since marrying her husband in 1992, charging documents state. She said she was expected to have sex with her husband whenever he wanted, day or night, and if the "sessions" didn’t work out the way he planned, she would be beaten.

"She said she didn’t want to have sex with him at all because of the beatings," court records state. "She claimed that she was in pain all the time because she didn’t have time to heal between beatings."

Butterfield said he was able to identify two specific instances where the man’s alleged conduct constituted rape, including once with a broom handle.

"She reported that right after that happened, and before she could care for herself, that he made her cower with her face in the corner until she had permission to leave the corner," court records state.

The couple’s children, ages 9 to 17, were not immune from abuse either, Butterfield said. The woman and her children told investigators that the man would keep track of the family’s food, including counting how many slices of cheese were in the refrigerator. Butterfield said when the youngest child ate a slice of cheese in 2008 without his father’s OK, he was thrown across a hallway by his hair, knocked to the ground and stomped on by the man, who was wearing heavy work boots.

(The woman) said she grabbed a two-by-four and hit (her husband) with it to get him to stop," court records state. "She said when she did this, he took (the board) from her and beat her with it."

Butterfield interviewed the man for three hours Thursday and said the man corroborated some of the allegations made by his wife. He acknowledged rationing food, the sergeant said, but said it was because "they were poor and the kids were wasteful," and alleged that his wife’s alcohol use and poor parenting led to many of the problems in the home.

"He tried to minimize and play the denial game," Butterfield said, "but in the end he recognized that there was violence in his home and that things were completely out of control."

The woman and her children have left Duchesne County and are doing well, according to investigators, considering what allegedly took place in their remote home.

"She’s healed up, and the weight of the world is off her shoulders," Butterfield said. "She doesn’t even look like the same person that I interviewed a few weeks ago."

The man is scheduled to make an initial court appearance Monday in 8th District Court for two counts of rape, both first-degree felonies, and one count each of aggravated assault and child abuse, both second-degree felonies. He is being held in the Duchesne County Jail in lieu of $160,000 bail.

Technorati Tags: ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,Note: Cross posted from [wp angelfury] Battered Mothers Rights – A Human Rights Issue.

Permalink

OHIO MOM NEEDS HELP NOW! 9 MONTH OLD RAPED~KILLED~ RUNNING OUT OF TIME TO KEEP MURDERDER IN JAIL

Posted in Uncategorized on 11/06/2009 by Claudine Dombrowski

Note: Cross posted from [wp angelfury] A Human Rights Issue-Custodial Justice.

Permalink

    ohio mom

    Here is her plea:

    In August of 1979 a baby just three months shy of her very first birthday was raped and beaten by a man named Christopher Cooper. Little Monica Williams laid in her hospital bed for five days fighting for her life because her little heart was strong and her mother says she was a fighter for sure. Poor little Monica lost the battle for her life on August 16, 1979.

    Monica’s mother, Becky Potter of Findlay, Ohio said, “I need to keep him in prison for this. There is no excuse, no excuse, and as long as I’m able to walk and my jaw is able to flap you will hear from me.”

    “She never had a chance to be a cheerleader graduate from high school, or go on to college,” she continued. “It’s very tough. All you have to do is look at the picture and see she was going to be a good girl.”

    Becky honestly thinks if this man is set free back into society, everyone will be in danger. The family is saying the best way to stop him from being released on parole would be for everyone they can find to write a letter to the parole board requesting he stay in prison and away from children.

    “He’s murdered once an infant,” says Monica’s uncle, Michael Saum. “If you can find an infant worthy of lusting over and the things he’s done to her, there is no excuse in it you can’t rehabilitate someone like that.”

    If you want to help the fight to keep this man in prison please send a letter to

    Ohio Board of Parole, Office of Victim Services

    770 W. Broad St.

    Columbus

    Ohio 43222

    You are asked to include the convicted killer’s name which is Christopher Cooper as well as his inmate number which is A158707. Each letter counts as one request no matter how many signatures you have on it. They say that all letters need to be signed, dated and include a return address on the envelope by December 1, 2009.

    Share

    ▼ Reply to This

    Bold Italic Underline Strikethrough Add Hyperlink Add an Image Upload a File

    Upload Files

    Replies to This Discussion

    AngelboundPermalink Reply by Angelbound 23 hours ago

    My Letter will be in the Mail this week! I will be copying and pasting little Monica’s photo at the Top of my Letter also, to make it so the Parole Board can see her little face when reading my letter! Adding a photo if you can, helps personalize the case file and the public’s objection. We have to Speak out for this tiny 9 months old baby that was Raped and Killed.

    Please help !!! WE ONLY HAVE A FEW WEEKS UNTIL DECEMBER 1ST TO GET OUR LETTERS TO PAROLE BOARD

    ▶ Reply to This

    John QuinnPermalink Reply by John Quinn 23 hours ago

    I will write a letter today and get it out.He should have been sentenced to death !! How can they even think of paroleing him ??? Love…john

    ▶ Reply to This

    DelilahPermalink Reply by Delilah 22 hours ago
    Send Message

    DRC.Victim.Services@odrc.state.oh.us

    Here is the email address to make it easier!

    Let’s get some letters to make sure this guy doesn’t get out!

    ▶ Reply to This

    DelilahPermalink Reply by Delilah 22 hours ago
    Send Message

    Phone

    614-752-1150

    Fax

    614-752-1171

    ▶ Reply to This

    FindmywayhomePermalink Reply by Findmywayhome 19 hours ago

    Delilah will an email have the same weight as a written letter. It would be easier to email but can write letter too if needed.

    Thanks

    Marie

    ▶ Reply to This

    AngelboundPermalink Reply by Angelbound 19 hours ago

    EVERYONE, I HAVE POSTED THIS BLOG FOR ONE OF OUR MEMBERS CYNDI!!!! SHE POSTED THIS IN THE GROUP FOR ABUSED CHILDREN,, AND I EMAILED HER ASKING PERMISSION TO POST IT ON THE FRONT PAGE SO THAT WE COULD HOPEFULLY GET MORE EYES ON THIS ASAP! WITH HER PERMISSION AND REQUEST, I POSTED THIS POST ON HER BEHALF AND THE FAMILIES BEHALF.

    I JUST WANTED TO SAY THANK YOU CYNDI FOR BRINGING THIS TO ALL OF OUR ATTENTIONS! HOPEFULLY WE CAN ALL PULL TOGETHER AND HELP THIS FAMILY…. HUGS..

    AND THANK YOU DELILAH FOR THE OTHER INFORMATION ALSO:

    ▶ Reply to This

    jerdonnaPermalink Reply by jerdonna 19 hours ago

    I will write it out when i get off of here,and put mine in the mail tommorrow,and i will get some of my friends to do the same there is no way he should ever get out,this system we have is really messed up and scary,we all should be able to live in PEACE, not fear and walk on egg shels all the time!!!!!

    ▶ Reply to This

    AngelboundPermalink Reply by Angelbound 19 hours ago

    Marie, A Snail Mailed letter through the Post office would hold more weight! They call it a paper trail for the file?

    However, both methods could be utilized, for example: follow up with an email also and even a phone call too!!! I’m extreamly greedy! when it comes to this type of need, and will use every method available in conjunction.

    OR: If it is the last few days and you know your hard copy letter would not make it before the deadline, Please everyone DO use the Email method! ( But we need Hard Copies Badly)

    I could stand corrected on this, and if anyone has any input, please do contribute! thank you…

    ▶ Reply to This

    LynxPermalink Reply by Lynx 18 hours ago

    I haven’t been online a lot lately,and haven’t been doing enough to help peace4themissing….this caught my eye today as I was hurriedly dealing with way too much,including some menacing behavior as well as a neighbor who had her home broken into as she was sleeping.THIS caught me just after those incidents…I was unable to grasp the title line;why in hell are"they" even considering now or ever letting this POS"out"…

    I will send this far and wide,thank you for also the fax phone and email addys.

    The entire country BETTER pull their heads out,this is getting to be….I have no words,it is still trying to get through my head&heart.

    R.I.P. little Monica

    My God,what’s it gonna take!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

     
    • Technorati Tags: ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,Note: Cross posted from [wp angelfury] A Human Rights Issue-Custodial Justice.

      Permalink

      Russell Vender used a .22-caliber rifle to murder his wife before shooting himself in the head

      Posted in Uncategorized on 11/06/2009 by Claudine Dombrowski

      http://www.phillyburbs.com/news/local/courier_times/courier_times_news_details/article/28/2009/november/06/deaths-ruled-a-murder-suicide.html

      Deaths ruled a murder-suicide

      TEXT SIZE Increase text size Decrease text size

      By: BEN FINLEY

      Bucks County Courier Times

      Russell Vender used a .22-caliber rifle to murder his wife before shooting himself in the head, the coroner said.

      A Bristol Township man shot his wife twice, in the head and upper chest, while she was in bed before he turned the rifle on himself Tuesday evening, the Bucks County coroner has ruled.

      Russell Vender, 54, used a .22-caliber rifle to murder his wife, Ethelyn Vender, 52, before getting in bed next to her and shooting himself in the head, Bucks County Coroner Joseph Campbell said Thursday. Vender then got out of the bed and collapsed in a nearby bathroom, where he died, Campbell said.

      Ethelyn Vender had filed for divorce last month. It appears the couple was still living together in the Holly Drive home that Ethelyn Vender owned, said Stacey L. Smith, the Bristol Township-based attorney whom Ethelyn Vender hired for the divorce.

      The divorce filing alleges that her husband cheated on her, threatened her with a crowbar and had a history of drug addiction. The divorce filing also describes fights the couple was having over money. Both were unemployed. Russell Vender was living on Social Security and workers’ compensation, according to the filing.

      This murder-suicide is similar to some previous murder-suicides in Bucks County in that the couple had recently separated or discussed separating, drugs had been an issue and the perpetrator was unemployed or on disability. That’s according to Linda Thomas, the Legal Advocacy Director for A Woman’s Place, a nonprofit advocacy group for victims of domestic violence in Bucks County.

      And this murder-suicide is like many other murder-suicides in America in that the perpetrator was male, it involved a gun and occurred between intimate partners in their home, according to a study by the Violence Policy Center, a national nonprofit that advocates more standards on firearms.

      According to Ethelyn Vender’s divorce filing, dated Oct. 15, the couple married in 1974 in Morrisville. She said in the court papers that she was seeking alimony and could not support herself financially.

      The filing accused Russell Vender of attacking her with the crowbar in 2006, shoving her during an argument in 2009 and being verbally abusive, saying things like "She will get what is coming to her."

      Smith, Ethelyn Vender’s divorce lawyer, said she was not aware of any protection from abuse orders that were filed by either of the victims.

      In 2008, Ethelyn Vender suffered a heart attack, due in part to stress, according to the filing. The divorce papers alleged that Russell Vender had been diagnosed as bi-polar and was addicted to morphine, for which he was seeking medical assistance to detoxify.

      Advertisement

      The divorce filing accused Russell Vender of trying to take control of their assets and finances. Ethelyn Vender had taken out $6,000 from one of their joint bank accounts, leaving about $35,000 in there. Russell Vender then removed her name from that account, preventing her from accessing those funds, the court filings stated.

      Ethelyn Vender was seeking exclusive possession of the house, which she owned, until the divorce proceedings were over.

      A man standing outside the Holly Drive home declined to comment on the matter to the newspaper.

      "It was a shock," Smith said about the deaths. "She was a very nice woman."

      In 2005, Bucks County suffered a rash of murder suicides in Warminster, Perkasie, Quakertown and Solebury. That prompted the District Attorney’s Office to create a fatality review commission on those deaths and several other domestic homicides, said Thomas of A Woman’s Place, who was part of the commission.

      "When the batterer feels that they’re losing control of the situation, it’s often times that you see the murder-suicides happen, or just murders," Thomas said. "There is an increased risk when the circumstances in a relationship change such as someone leaving."

      Other risk factors include the perpetrator stalking the victim and trying to control who the victim is friends with, where they go and how much money they spend, Thomas said.

      Easy access to a gun is also a common denominator, she said. Police believe Russell Vender owned the .22 rifle.

      The fatality review commission found that educating potential victims of all the available support is important to preventing murder-suicides or domestic homicides.

      That includes making people aware of groups like A Woman’s Place, which offers counseling, hot lines, incident response teams and a domestic violence program. The police also are crucial as are family doctors after a beating, family members and friends, Thomas said.

      The county has secured a grant to provide training to local police for when they respond to domestic violence calls, Thomas said.

      Physical violence does not always precede a murder-suicide, Thomas said.

      "Often times, it’s just the verbal abuse that’s going on and the whole psychological piece of it," she said. "It’s important for victims not to isolate themselves and to talk to people about what’s going on."

      Athens Police Investigate Murder-Suicide

      Posted in Uncategorized on 11/06/2009 by Claudine Dombrowski

      http://www.coosavalleynews.com/np82581.htm

      Athens Police Investigate Murder-Suicide

      Tony Potts
      11-06-2009

      A shooting Thursday has lead police to investigate a murder-suicide in Athens. After a woman`s body was found in a parked car about a mile from the University of Georgia campus an alert was issued that told students to avoid the school`s golf course, where the shooter had been spotted. Police then found the suspect dead 10 miles from campus in Oglethorpe County from a self-inflicted gunshot wound.

      Police did not say how the victims knew each other.

      Technorati Tags: ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,

      Father shoots son and wife in head then kills self

      Posted in Uncategorized on 11/06/2009 by Claudine Dombrowski

      http://www.newarkadvocate.com/article/20091106/NEWS01/911060305/1002/Police-probe-possible-murder-suicide

      John Eckard, 46, Robin Eckard, 45, and Nicholas Michael Gabriel Eckard, 9, were found dead by police around 8:25 a.m. Thursday in their 13160 Havens Corner Road SW home in Pataskala.

      John Eckard, 46, Robin Eckard, 45, and Nicholas Michael Gabriel Eckard, 9, were found dead by police around 8:25 a.m. Thursday in their 13160 Havens Corner Road SW home in Pataskala. (Michael Lehmkuhle, The Advocate)

       

      PATASKALA — The bodies of a couple and their 9-year-old son were discovered early Thursday inside their ranch-style home in what police are calling a possible double murder-suicide.

      Prompted by a 911 call, police found John Eckard, 46, Robin Eckard, 45, and Nicholas Michael Gabriel Eckard, 9, on Thursday morning in their 13160 Havens Corner Road SW home, Pataskala Police Chief Chris Forshey said.

      "It would appear they died of (single gunshot wounds) to the head," Forshey said.

      Police found two of the victims in their respective bedrooms and the suspected shooter in the living room, but Forshey would not confirm the identity of the suspected shooter pending planned autopsies today.

      Forshey placed the estimated time of death for all three victims at between 3 and 8:25 a.m. Police forced their way into the home not long after the 911 call came in at 8:34 a.m.

      "Our preliminary indications are that two of them were probably shot while they slept," Forshey said.

      He added the wounds appeared to come from a shotgun, and there were no signs of a struggle inside the home.

      "It was a violent crime scene," Forshey said. "One of the more violent I’ve seen."

      The Licking County 911 Center received a call Thursday morning from a man worried about a letter he had just received.

      The center transferred the call to the Licking County Sheriff’s Office, and the male caller can be heard in a recording of the call telling a dispatcher that John Eckard left him three hand-typed letters in his office, which is in the same building as John Eckard’s business. He also left letters for his ex-wife, the caller said.

      "It says ‘please don’t open this ’till 11,’" said the male caller, describing the letter left for him. "Then it says we are no longer in this world …"

      The caller tells the dispatcher John Eckard has "serious medical problems." Later in the call, he describes the problems as Parkinson’s disease.

      A concerned-sounding woman can be heard in the background as the man hurriedly explains the situation to the dispatcher.

      Police said Thursday they think John Eckard owned Alpha Auto Group, 13375 National Road.

      Police also said they recovered at least four letters they suspect John Eckard left at his business and at his home. He also sent text messages to a business partner and family and friends around 3:15 a.m., police said. The text messages contained similar subject matter as the letters, Forshey said.

      The family lived in a two-story, ranch-style home that stood abut 200 yards off Havens Corner Road. A long driveway, immaculate lawns and several trees and a gentle slope stood between the home and the road, making it difficult to see the entire home from the road.

      On Thursday, yellow police caution tape surrounded the front and side lawns. A trampoline and wooden play-set occupied a section of the side yard. A barn and horse corral stood behind the home, and several Halloween decorations, including bales of hay, pumpkins and decorative scarecrows, remained on the front lawn.

      The family had not been on the police department’s radar before Thursday, Forshey said.

      "This is not a place we routinely come to," Forshey said. "I do think they had a barn fire last summer, though."

      Police think Nicholas Eckard attended one of two Licking Heights elementary schools on Summit Road. Licking Heights Superintendent Thomas Tucker could not be reached Thursday to confirm that.

      Thursday marked the second time in eight months the city has witnessed a possible murder-suicide.

      In February, Jeffrey P. McKnight, 53, set fire to his Amber Road home, then went to the Summit Road home of his father, Charles E. McKnight, 94, and stabbed him to death before turning a gun on himself.

      The Amber Road home was in foreclosure at the time of the incident.

      Police on Thursday still were exploring motives regarding the shootings on Havens Corner Road.

      "I believe there were a number of issues that may have contributed to this," said Forshey, adding he could not elaborate.

      Chad Klimack can be reached at (740) 927-3738 or cklimack@nncogannett.com.

      Miami-Dade couple dies in possible murder-suicide

      Posted in Uncategorized on 11/06/2009 by Claudine Dombrowski

      http://www.miamiherald.com/news/breaking-news/story/1319782.html

      Miami-Dade couple dies in possible murder-suicide

      BY LISA CILLI
      CBS4.COM

      A fight between an estranged South Florida couple led to gunfire and now both people are dead, according to police.

      Miami-Dade police responded to a "woman in distress call" at 19090 NW 57th Ave. shortly after 10 p.m. Thursday and discovered a man and woman had both been shot.

      The man was dead on the scene. The woman was transported to the hospital, where she later died. Family members told CBS 4 that the woman was a corrections officer.

      Neighbors were shocked to hear about the violence.

      "It’s crazy, it’s just crazy. I mean I don’t know what could have been so bad where that could happen," said one neighbor.

      The preliminary investigation revealed the couple was estranged and got into an argument that escalated to gunfire.

      No other information has been released.

      ‘‘He was a Wonderful Husband and Father’’- But Shoots and Kills Wife and Two Daughters Before Shooting Self.

      Posted in Uncategorized on 11/04/2009 by Claudine Dombrowski

       

      http://www.fayobserver.com/Articles/2009/11/04/948992

      Published: 06:17 AM, Wed Nov 04, 2009

      Family tragedy: Murder-suicide shocks, saddens

      By Nancy McCleary and Francis X. Gilpin
      Staff writers

      People who knew Billy Maxwell Jr. tried Tuesday to understand why the man known as a wonderful husband and father shot and killed his wife and two teenage children before turning the gun on himself.

      "It’s like a nightmare," said Cyndi McKinney, a business partner and close friend of Maxwell.

      "It has shattered the staff and students," said Lena Scott, interim administrator of Village Christian Academy, where the children attended school. "It’s just overwhelming sorrow."

      Police say Maxwell, 47, shot and killed his family – his wife, Kathryn, and children, Connor and Cameron – inside their home at 314 W. Park Drive on Monday night.

      Kathryn Maxwell’s parents reportedly found the bodies inside the house about 8 p.m. and called 911.

      Word quickly spread through Fayetteville about the fate of the prominent businessman and his family.

      Shock and disbelief were followed by the question: Why?

      To many, the Maxwells appeared to be a model family. They were deeply involved in Snyder Memorial Baptist Church. Billy Maxwell, a developer, coached his son’s basketball team. Kathryn Maxwell was involved with the Junior League of Fayetteville and a strong supporter of her children’s school and athletic programs. Connor, a cheerleader at Village Christian Academy, was a Girl Scout working on her gold award. Her brother, Cameron, was a freshmantrying out for the junior varsity basketball team.

      Adam Ancherico, a family friend, said Maxwell did everything with his family.

      The Maxwells regularly attended University of North Carolina football games in Chapel Hill together, Ancherico said.

      Last month, the family traveled to Boone so 17-year-old Connor could see if she wanted to continue her education at Appalachian State University, Ancherico said.

      "Billy was as adamant about making sure he was bringing up his kids in a Christian family as anybody I know," he said. "And he was doing that."

      Ancherico said he was especially impressed with Maxwell’s 15-year-old son, Cameron.

      "His son is the model boy," Ancherico said. "If the good Lord said pick your son out, I’d just say: ‘Make me a twin of that Maxwell boy right there.’ "

      School reaction

      Administrators at Village Christian Academy High School, where the children were students, said they learned of the deaths Monday night when they received calls from parents and students.

      "We’re all shocked," said the school’s principal, Dr. William Warren.

      Students gathered Tuesday morning for an assembly to talk about the family.

      There were tears, but there also were smiles and laughter as students, teachers and former staff members remembered the family and shared stories, Warren said.

      Connor was looking forward to graduation next year and going to college, Warren said.

      "She was very quiet, very studious," he said.

      Friends said Connor was hiding in a closet when she was shot.

      Cameron "was always full of life," Warren said.

      At the assembly, a former teacher recalled how Cameron and a friend made beards by taping shreds of paper to their faces, Warren said.

      When the teacher, who had been involved in something else, turned around, Cameron and his friend threw themselves on the ground where the beards wouldn’t be seen, Warren said.

      Supportive mother

      Kathryn Maxwell was well known to students and faculty because of her constant support for the school and its sports program, Warren said.

      McKinney, the business associate and close friend of Maxwell, said Kathryn had "that Southern sweetness, and she always wanted to do the right thing."

      McKinney sat for a long time Tuesday afternoon in her car outside the Maxwells’ spacious home on a hill overlooking a park between East and West Park drives. She wiped away tears as she talked about the family.

      McKinney, like others, can’t fathom what happened to Billy Maxwell, a man she described as a "brilliant businessman."

      Allen Smith, a Fayetteville lawyer, played on the Terry Sanford High School basketball team with Maxwell in the late 1970s.

      Like others who knew Maxwell, he was in shock Tuesday.

      "I’ll put it this way," he said. "If you were to line up 3,000 people and say who’s the most likely to do this at random, Billy would be 2,999 or 3,000."

      Monday night, McKinney’s husband, John, was at the home of Bill Maxwell, Billy’s father, when the phone rang. It was Bill Maxwell’s daughter asking her father to come to her home immediately.

      "(Maxwell) said, ‘I hope nothing’s happened to Billy,’ " Cyndi McKinney said.

      Staff writer Nancy McCleary can be reached at mcclearyn@fayobserver.com or 486-3568. Staff writer Francis X. Gilpin can be reached at gilpinf@fayobserver.com of 486-3587.

      Man Kills 2 Children, Self; Wife Came Out Of Shower To Find Her Family Dead

      Posted in Uncategorized on 11/04/2009 by Claudine Dombrowski

      http://www.news4jax.com/news/21506311/detail.html

      Deputies Say Wife Came Out Of Shower To Find Her Family Dead

      POSTED: Tuesday, November 3, 2009

      UPDATED: 10:28 pm EST November 3, 2009

      Fleming Island double murder-suicide

      Clay County deputies were called to a report of a triple shooting at a house in the Margaret’s Walk subdivision just of U.S. Highway 17 on Fleming Island.

      FLEMING ISLAND, Fla. — A Clay County woman called 911 early Tuesday morning to report finding her husband and two children dead in what investigators believe was a double slaying and suicide.

      Clay County Sheriff’s Office Sgt. Dan Mahla said it appears that 49-year-old Jerry Whitelaw shot his 16-year-old son, Kevin, and 11-year-old daughter, Katie, inside their home on Grande Oaks Way in the Margaret’s Walk subdivision just after 6 a.m. before turning the gun on himself.

      Mahla said they believe the two children were killed in their sleep, then Whitelaw shot himself while his wife was in the shower.

      "It has the appearance of being a murder-suicide," Mahla said. "Anytime it’s involving children, it’s devastating."

      Kevin and Katie Whitelaw

      Kevin Whitelaw, 16, and Katie Whitelaw, 11, were found dead in their Fleming Island home. Deputies believe their father killed them before pulling the trigger on himself.

      Grief counselors were available at the two children’s schools: St. Johns Country Day and Grace Episcopal Day School. Dana Whitelaw also works as a secretary at Grace Episcopal.

      "Our prayers are with the entire family," said the Rev. Kurt Dunkle of Grace Episcopal. "In times like this, it is only God that you can rely on and who will be there to pick up the pieces."

      Greg Foster, the headmaster of St. Johns Country Day, where Kevin was a student and played on the football team, said the school announced what happened before class Tuesday.

      "Our students and our teachers care very deeply about each other," Foster said. "The kids and the adults know each other, care about each other a lot. The terrible news this morning has left our school with a profound sense of loss."

      Multimedia:

      Candlelight Vigil Held For Family
      Deputies Identify Dead In Double Murder-Suicide
      Neighbors, School React To Deaths
      Deputies Respond To Triple Homicide

      William McGauley, the father of Dana Whitelaw, issued this statement on behalf of the family Tuesday afternoon:

        “On behalf of my daughter, Dana, I would like to thank the families of Grace Episcopal Day School, Grace Episcopal Church, and St. Johns Country Day School for their incredible outpouring of love, support, and prayers for my family. I cannot tell you how much it means to my daughter and the rest of my family to know how much we are loved.

        "There are no words to describe this loss. The enormity of this tragedy cannot be absorbed in such a short period of time. The grief we feel is overwhelming, and so we ask for and appreciate your patience as we make the necessary arrangements to lay our family members to rest.”

      Court records show Dana Whitelaw had filed for divorce in August. While the sheriff’s office had no record of previous police calls to the home, Mahla said, "There were some domestic issues."

      A neighbor told Channel 4’s Dan Leveton that she saw Jerry Whitelaw and the kids outside Monday night and everything appeared to be fine. She told Channel 4’s Jim Piggott she had not heard the couple was getting a divorce until after the shootings.

      "It’s crazy," neighbor Ashley Gann said. "I was in total shock."

      Deputies continued to gather evidence at the home in the gated community off U.S. Highway 17 just north of Green Cove Springs.

      The community held a prayer candlelight vigil for Kevin and Katie Whitelaw Tuesday night at Grace Episcopal Church in the wake of the tragedy. About 700 people gathered at the church in Orange Park, which had standing room only.

      "Our hearts go out to them and our prayers," said a friend of the family who attended the vigil. "We just love Dana, and God bless Kevin and Katie."

      This case joins the ongoing investigation into the disappearance and slaying of 7-year-old Somer Thompson, a recent double slaying at a Fleming Island nightclub and other high-profile crimes. The sheriff’s office of this bedroom community of Jacksonville admits it is being stretched.

      "I think our whole agency is maxed to the limit right now," Mahla said. "Thank goodness that we’ve had the Federal Bureau of Investigation, the Florida Department of Law Enforcement, the United States Marshals, NCIS and a lot of our neighboring agencies have come down to help us at this time."

      Copyright 2009 by News4Jax.com. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

      Brutal carjacking not only killed mom, but separated kids

      Posted in Uncategorized on 11/04/2009 by Claudine Dombrowski

      "The brutality and violence … haunt all family members …"

      McKinney

      Related coverage

      » JAIL INMATES: Learn more about everyone arrested in Duval County in the last 31 days
      » HOMICIDES DATABASE: Learn more about Duval County’s homicides since 2004 in a searchable database.
      » First Coast Fugitives
      » More crime and public safety coverage

      Santeris T. McKinney not only killed a mother of two young children when he slammed the van he had carjacked head-on into the sedan being driven by Amanda C. Rengifo, he set in motion a legal procedure that has separated those two siblings.

      Since the mother’s death, the father of the oldest child obtained custody and took her to live with him in Orlando.

      Tessie Romero, Rengifo’s aunt, read a statement on behalf of the 24-year-old victim’s family at a hearing Tuesday before Circuit Judge Michael R. Weatherby. Weatherby will impose sentence on McKinney Nov. 12 after taking under advisement some double jeopardy issues. The sentence could range from 13 years to life since McKinney is an habitual offender.

      A jury took less than an hour Sept. 30 after a two-day trial to convict McKinney of third-degree murder, vehicular homicide, carjacking and aggravated fleeing in the Jan. 12 death of Rengifo.

      He had carjacked a van from a schoolteacher who was getting gas at a Southside service station and then was followed by police down Southside Boulevard and Baymeadows Road until he sped up to as fast as 100 mph.

      McKinney turned into Deerwood Park Boulevard where he trampled a median and careened around a curve before hitting Rengifo’s sedan. The van overturned and caught fire, and investigators said the victim’s car was pushed back 91 feet by the force of the crash.

      Romero, in reading her family’s statement, said the victim’s two children, Lisabel, 6, and Emilio, 3, have now been separated because the girl’s father filed for legal custody after Rengifo’s death.

      Romero said Lisabel has now been taken from her extended family and her father does not allow her to have any contact with her brother or her mother’s family.

      "Emilio is always asking when he is going home," Romero said. "In his mind, if he goes home, then his mom and sister will be there."

      She said that besides the family suffering financial hardships, including funeral costs and legal costs involving Lisabel’s custody, "the brutality and violence of the accident haunt all family members every day. We suffer from bad dreams and disturbed sleep. We have an indwelling sense of anger, disbelief, shock and unresolved loss."

      She asked the judge to send McKinney to prison for life "so there will not be another person taken from their family too early."

      McKinney’s relatives also spoke, begging for mercy saying he was adopted by an aunt after his mother became a street person who eventually died. They included a pastor, Louis Parker, and a Jacksonville firefighter, James McKinney.

      Though both said they could not justify McKinney’s crimes and expressed sorrow for the victim’s family, they admitted he made bad choices and "got away from the church."

      McKinney read a statement to the judge, expressing his sorrow for the life lost. "I never meant to hurt anyone," he said.

      jessie-lynne.kerr@ jacksonville.com, (904) 359-4374

      Deputies name suspect, victim in apparent murder-suicide (WI)

      Posted in Uncategorized on 11/04/2009 by Claudine Dombrowski

      http://www.jsonline.com/news/milwaukee/68905257.html

      By Sharif Durhams of the Journal Sentinel

      Posted: Nov. 3, 2009

      Authorities say a Stone Lake man who killed the uncle of his child and then killed himself had a vendetta against the murder victim’s family.

      The man suspected in the murder, Arthur A. Garcia, 31, told several people Saturday night that he had killed David W. Palm, 43, of Birchwood. Rescue workers discovered Palm’s body that night in a burning house in Edgewater.

      Sheriff’s deputies found Garcia’s body several hours later after he had shot himself near a mobile home in Washburn County and had burned himself on a pile of tires.

      Investigators found pipe bombs in a backpack near Garcia’s body and found two handguns. They say they believe one of the guns was used to kill Palm.

      Authorities formally identified Garcia’s body Tuesday, but had said Monday that they believed the body they discovered in Washburn County was the suspect in Palm’s death.

      Garcia and the mother of his child had broken up about two years ago. Investigators believe Garcia blamed family members for the breakup and said Garcia and his child’s mother had disputes over custody of the child.